you're trying to use two MFi (Made for iPhone/iPad) game controllers for multiplayer gaming — but both keep registering as Player One — you're not alone. This is a common issue, but luckily, it has some reliable solutions.

Here’s a full guide on how to fix it and enjoy smooth multiplayer gaming on iOS, iPadOS, tvOS, or macOS.

Why Do Both Controllers Show as Player One?
This usually happens due to:

Software bugs in iOS/tvOS

Controllers not fully supported for multiplayer mode

Game not recognizing two unique input devices

Controller profile conflict (especially with generic brands)

How to Fix 2 MFi Controllers Pairing as Player One
1.  Restart Your Device and Controllers
Power off both controllers

Restart your iPhone/iPad/Apple TV

Reconnect one controller at a time via Bluetooth settings

2.  Use the Correct Game
Not all games support local multiplayer on iOS/tvOS.
Make sure the game supports multiple controllers.
Examples: Asphalt 8, Oceanhorn 2, NBA 2K

3.  Forget and Re-pair Controllers
Go to Settings > Bluetooth

Tap the (i) icon next to the controller

Select Forget This Device

Re-pair them one by one

4.  Use the Right Controller Types
Some older MFi controllers don’t support full multi-controller pairing.
Try using different brands (e.g., one Xbox controller and one MFi) to test compatibility.

5. Use Apple TV or Mac for Better Support
Apple TV and macOS handle multiple controller inputs more reliably than iPhones or iPads.
Connect both controllers to your Apple TV and test a supported multiplayer game.